• Blog
  • About
    • My Inks (on Fountain Pen Companion)
    • My Pens
  • Archive
  • Contact
Menu

Macchiato Man

  • Blog
  • About
  • My Collection ☟
    • My Inks (on Fountain Pen Companion)
    • My Pens
  • Archive
  • Contact
The @madebyendless Cotton Wallet arrived the other day! I’m a sucker for these sorts of practical inserts for notebooks. The cotton fabric suites the simple style of the Explorer. 
⠀
While I love these and always get them whenever I can I never
First test of the Regalia paper in the Endless Explorer than I was sent by @madebyendless. Really impressed by the paper. Very smooth, nice sheen and nice shading! Finger prints or hand oil seem to affect the writing a little but nothing out of the o
New Pen Review: Esterbrook Camden (Premium Edition) - 𝙻𝚒𝚗𝚔 𝚒𝚗 𝙱𝚒𝚘!

I’ve been eager to try the Camden for a while now. I love my flat end pens and the overall shape of this one is subtly unique. While there are some differences between
New friend from @esterbrook_official! Camden Manitoba Blue. 
⠀
Love flat end pens so looking forward to digging into this (so review incoming).
 
Flat or round ends?✑
⠀
⠀
⠀
⠀
#fountainpen #fpgeeks #fountainpenaddict #fpn #fountainpengeeks  #fountainp
New Ink Review: @birminghampens Antique Sepia (link in bio)
⠀
In line with the recent trend of soft pastel dichromatic inks but Birmingham’s version is an interesting dust grey version with low saturation that I find quite interesting don&rsquo
New Ink Day! Haven’t had one of these for a while but I received these from a friend at the last Perth Pen Meet. 
⠀
All sailor and the first tall bottle in a while (bringing the number of those to 86). 
⠀
Didn’t realise it at the time but
New Ink Review: La Couronne du Comte Vert Sapin (link in bio)
⠀
The final of LCdC’s initial set of four exclusive inks from Diamine. A lovely rich sheeny green-teal.
✑
⠀
⠀
⠀
⠀
#fountainpen #fpgeeks #fountainpenaddict #fpn #fountainpengeeks  #fo
I don’t know if I’ve ever shared this before but my city has a set of five dip nibs as an artwork. 

They are called “Memory Markers” by Anne Neil and represent early-ish colonial stories of the gardens where they are.

We als
⚠️Update: Why I have been so radio silent! 📻🤫 A lot of large personal changes, essentially (read on for details)!

There have been three main reasons for why I haven’t been able to do much here or on my blog. 

1) 🎓 I had to finish of my Mas
Ink Ink Comparison: Discontinued Iroshizuku and New Iroshizuku! Thanks to @penclassics for allowing this to happen. See link in bio!
⠀
The old: Tsuyu-kusa, Tsukushi, and Ina-ho.
The New: Sui-gyoku, Hana-ikada, and Hotaru-bi.
⠀
This is a long review b
NPD: @esterbrook_official LE Estie “Candy” in Oversize with a Kirk Speer Needlepoint nib!
⠀
Thanks to Esterbrook for sending this through to me for review. I’ve reviewed a couple of Esties now and two of the custom nibs (which are a
Out with the old in with the new?

I just received the new Pilot Iroshizuku Inks in the little bottle ink pack from @penclassics for review. I plan on doing an overview review of the three new and the three old ones!

I feel like Ina Ho was quite a u
New Pen Review (see link in bio): Platinum Curidas courtesy of @penclassics (check them out!)
⠀
This is certainly a curiously designed pen with it's quirks but it has bee a delight to write with and a great pen to through in a pocket. I've been using
New Ink Review! @wearingeul_global Kyonghui! See link in bio!

Kyonghui is a vibrant earthy orange from Wearingeul's series on Korean Female Modern Writers. It is also a great performing ink!

Wearingeul's global push is fairly new; has anyone tried
It has been a little while since I posted here so I thought I'd give a little update!

Firstly I think I just needed a little break at the end of the year! It has been a busy year for me. I have been taking my photography more seriously and I also ha

Subscribe

Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

Thank you!
Blog RSS

☛ Twitter feed

✉ Email Subscription

☞ Fountain Pens Australia (Facebook Group)

☛ Sailor Pens & Inks (Facebook Group)


Sponsors

10% off code: MACCHIATOMAN


Click here for sponsorship information


Featured Posts:

Featured
Ink Review: Pennonia Pokoltuz (Pokoltűz)
Aug 1, 2019
Ink Review: Pennonia Pokoltuz (Pokoltűz)
Aug 1, 2019
Aug 1, 2019
Notebook Review: Pebble Stationery Pocket Tomoe River Notebook
Nov 10, 2018
Notebook Review: Pebble Stationery Pocket Tomoe River Notebook
Nov 10, 2018
Nov 10, 2018
Ink Review: Krishna Brown Pink
Jan 20, 2018
Ink Review: Krishna Brown Pink
Jan 20, 2018
Jan 20, 2018


Archive
  • November 2024
  • October 2023
  • December 2022
  • October 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
Logo 1.jpg

Pen Review: Montblanc Heritage 1912 with Masuyama grind

July 20, 2018 in Pen Review

Montblanc released the Heritage 1912 in 2013 as a homage to their safety pens of the early 20th century. The 1912 is a piston filler with a retractable nib and a small profile (when capped) but a normal well weighted pen when uncapped. This is a bit of a different review as the pen isn't a stock pen from the manufacturer; the nib has been modified by Mike Masuyama. 

The Montblanc Heritage 1912 is a mostly flat-top pen that is a curious hybrid between a pocket pen when capped, and a normal pen when uncapped. The pen has resin with a brass interior giving the pen a very decent amount of heft to it. It has platinum coated fittings on the cap and a rhodium plated 14k nib. The barrel is almost completely uniformly thick but does slowly widen to the piston grip at the back of the pen before tapering a little quicker to the finial.

The Heritage 1912 is a homage to old Montblanc Safety Filler pens which are similar in that they have a retractable nib but different in that they are eye eye droppered into where the nib sits when retracted (the nib sits in the ink).

Packaging and paraphernalia 

Box 1.JPG
Box 2.JPG
Box 3.JPG
Box 4.JPG
Box 5.JPG
Box and Booklet.JPG
Pen in box 2.JPG
Box 1.JPG Box 2.JPG Box 3.JPG Box 4.JPG Box 5.JPG Box and Booklet.JPG Pen in box 2.JPG

The pen comes in a simple white cardboard outer box which (thankfully) has the nib size on it. Inside that is another thin cardboard box, that is, this time, not plane white but bears the Montblanc insignia as a greyscale design for the Heritage 1912. Within this box is a third box and a booklet. Thankfully this is the last box made and is made of a harder and thicker cardboard and is where the 1912 rests on a soft grey padded fabric. There's a fair amount of packaging here.

View fullsize Booklet 1.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 2.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 3.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 4.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 5.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 6.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 7.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 8.JPG
View fullsize Booklet 9.JPG

The booklet features some somewhat hyperbolic marketing jargon. "Divine the future", "setting standards of ingenuity", "uncompromising by design", "thinking beyond technology", "redefining the refine", "evolution of an icon"… This is a beautifully designed pen with a fun and interesting mechanism but to me the excessive buzzwords almost undermine the beautiful design and the interesting mechanisms.

Cap

View fullsize Clip.JPG
View fullsize Made in German Clip.JPG
View fullsize Mountain TOp.JPG
View fullsize Mountaintop side.JPG
View fullsize Cap Sunny.JPG

The platinum-plated clip which extends and wraps around the end of the cap is relatively unadorned with only a slight ark and and a soft ridge as a spine. The clip divides into two bands that wrap around the cap and then join on the other side to provide space for a debossed Montblanc mountain-top insignia. Stamped on the top divided band is the serial number for the pen and underneath the clip is "Made in Germany". Past the platinum bands is a small grip-like strip that doesn't seem to serve a functional purpose but may be there to balance, visually, with the grip on the piston on the barrel. The finial of the cap is a large shallowly rounded dome. Inside the dome is a raised mother-of-pearl lacquer Montblanc mountain top encased in some sort of plastic. This is a particularly unique and beautiful render of the Montblanc logo that doesn't actually stand out all that much as the actual star shape is only subtly discernible from the mother-of-pearl lacquer it is raised out of. I'm a big fan of this design and because of the convex lens nature of the plastic encasing, the mountain top logo is refracted when viewed from the side; a nice effect.

The cap doesn't post. At all. This is a little unfortunate given that you have to remove the cap, place it somewhere, and then unscrew the nib. A handy place would be the end of the pen (not that I ever post my pens). This is exactly how Montblanc Bohème pens work (and indeed the cap is used to twist the nib-extender. I understand, however, that this might make the pen very back heavy when writing, however.

View fullsize Cap Innter-Bar 2.JPG
View fullsize Feed.JPG

Inside the cap is a blunt metal nail. The point of this nail is the prevent damage of the nib if you accidentally attempt to screw the cap on before retracting the nib. It fits into an indented section on the plastic feed to stop the nib from touching the end of the cap.

IMG_8010.jpg

A flaw of this pen is that the nib creates a mark on the barrel. This is something universally reported by owners. It seems to be rumoured that Montblanc fixed this at some point and I've also read that the marking is due to a metal ring in the cap but my cap has a rubber ring in the cap so it's possible that it was adjusted. Nevertheless, my Heritage 1912 does have a ring mark from the cap. Mine looks more like a smudge than a scratch compares to what definitely looks like a scratch here but some light polishing doesn't affect it at all. 

Filling and nib extension mechanism

View fullsize Filling Mechanism.JPG
View fullsize Nib Unextended SUNNY 1.JPG
View fullsize Nib Unextended SUNNY 2.JPG
View fullsize Pen Bottle Pad SUNNY 3.JPG

The filling mechanism, which is a piston filler, of the pen is definitely fascinating because it is tied into the retraction mechanism. Most pens that have a nib-retraction mechanism are cartridge converters (Visconti Pininfarina, Lamy Dialog 3, Pilot Vanishing Point, Pilot Fermo, or Montblanc's own Bohème line of which some even only hold a converter) but the Montblanc Heritage 1912 builds the Piston into nib-retraction mechanism. With the piston flush with the rest of the barrel, turning it will extend and retract the nib. If you pull on the piston and extent it you engage the filling mechanism. Turning it now will push down and pull up the piston. This pen doesn't have the biggest ink capacity and this is possibly due to the resin and brass barrel material and the mechanism needing to fill two rolls. At 0.8ml this is around the size of a cartridge or a converter and not in line with the filling capacities of most piston fillers (Pelikan M600 has 1.3ml; Lamy 2000 has 1.2ml; TWSBI Eco, 1.8ml; and TWSBI Diamond 580, 2ml).

Nib

View fullsize Nib 4.JPG
View fullsize Nib 8.JPG
View fullsize Nib 1.JPG
View fullsize Nib and Mountaintop 2.JPG

There isn't really a grip section top this pen unless you want to call the ≈4mm flat section before the threads a grip section (which I don't). The threads aren't sharp so there's no issue holding the pen over them or half over them and half over the 4mm flat section before it, for me at least, but I believe the pen was meant to be held further back past the threads.

The nib has a slightly reserved design to it without any baroque ornamentation and a rather straight forward nib shape. Even the breather whole has a modern feeling to it as it is a sharp-cornered triangle.

The nib feel is very nice and soft. As it's a broad nib already it's difficult to determine whether the softness provides much line variation but I don't believe it would. This softness is a nib-feel softness rather than a written-line feature. The nib doesn't write all that wet; I wouldn't call it dry but it's definitely not wet. A wet ink, while not necessary, is more pleasant to me in this pen than a dry ink.

The nib is not a stock nib. It started as a Broad nib from Montblanc but was sent to Mike Masuyama to turn it into a Broad Cursive Italic. A Cursive Italic is meant to be sharper than stub nib and generally provides greater line width variation between the vertical and horizontal strokes with the horizontal strokes being very thin. A Cursive Italic is less sharp than a Formal Italic and provides slightly less vertical and horizontal line width variation. Rotating a Cursive Italic too much (which is easier to do than with a stub and a lot easier than with a regular round nib such as a medium) will often mean the corners of the Cursive Italic grind will dig into the paper. the nib catching a little gives a very sharp feel to the nib, which can be pleasant, but sometimes if you rotate too much and the nib catches too much then it isn't pleasant at all. You definitely need to try and keep the flat part of the nib flat agains the paper. This isn't an issue for me but if you are someone who routinely rotates the nib this might be an issue (though fortunately there are Oblique nibs for this very reason). The nib does it's job very nicely with some crisp thin horizontal lines and fatter vertical lines. If you remain perfectly flat with no rotation this nib is beautifully smooth and the bounce from the softer nib emphasises it. The nib on this pen is very nice and this is something I hear from other other owners of stock nib 1912s as well but the Mike Masuyama Cursive Italic grind is the cherry on top.

The nib doesn't dry out when uncapped and with the nib extended (within reason) which is good given that this is a pen that lends itself to being uncapped for extended periods.

Top to bottom: Franklin-Christoph steel #6 nib with Masuyama Broad Cursive Italic, Lamy Safari 14k Gold Safari nib with Masuyama Broad Cursive Italic Visconti 23k palladium nib with stock 1.3 Stub grind, Montblanc Heritage 1912 14k gold nib with Masuyama Broad Cursive Italic, Lamy Safari steel nib with stock 1.5 stub, and TWSBI ECO steel nib with stock 1.1 grind.

I have three Masuyama ground nibs, including this one on the Montblanc Heritage 1912. One of them is a steel #6 nib direct from Franklin-Christoph and the other is a 14k gold Lamy Safari nib. All of them are broad, coincidentally. The feel of the 14k Lamy is fairly similar to that of the Montblanc; very smooth without any rotation. The Lamy is a little broader on the vertical stroke and a little thinner on the horizontal stroke than the Montblanc and possibly a touch wetter. The Franklin-Christoph is noticeably thinner on the vertical and also a bit drier.

I mention above that that Cursive Italics are meant to have more line variation than stubs especially with the thin horizontal line but my steel stock Lamy 1.5 stub is fairly thin on the horizontal stroke. The TWSBI Eco 1.1 stub as well is not too bad. They both, however, don't quite have the crisp feeling to them that Cursive Italic nibs give but also have more leeway regarding rotation. The crisp feeling is probably a prominent love it or hate it feature of a cursive italic. For me this crisp feeling of the nib giving some feedback on slight rotations is pleasant but others might not like this.

Dimensions, weight, and feel

The curious thing about this pen is that it is actually longer when uncapped (and the nib extended) than it is when capped! This means the pen is very much in the pocket pen size capped but a normal size pen when uncapped. And that's without the need to post the cap which most pocket pens need before they are the size of a normal pen.

Where this pen is not a pocket pen is with its weight. It's heavier than the quite-large OMAS Paragon. The cap alone (11.7g) is heavier than an uncapped Lamy Safari (11g). This is why even if the pen was able to post it might be too back heavy to be practical.

The pen is also very evenly balanced from front to back but this means that it feels somewhat back heavy. Many pens are heavier towards the nib but because this is even it feels different. I don't consider this uncomfortable or unbalanced but it's definitely you can feel.

Capped Uncapped
Montblanc Heritage 1912 49.4g/1.74oz 37.7g/1.33oz
OMAS Arco Paragon 49g/1.73oz 35g/1,23oz
Lamy Safari 20g/0.70oz 11g/0.39oz
Lamy 2000 26g/0.91oz 17.1g/0.60
Platinum Century #3776 25g/0.88oz 14g/0.49oz
Sailor Pro Gear 24g/0.84oz 15g/0.53oz
Left to right: Pilot Custom 91 (Tsuki-yo), TWSBI Eco (white), Pelikan M805 (Ocean Swirl), Lamy 2000, Lamy Safari (Dark Lilac), Montblanc Heritage 1912, Montblanc Le Grand 146, Visconti Homo Sapiens (Bronze Age), Platinum Century #3776 (Rhodium Chart…

Left to right: Pilot Custom 91 (Tsuki-yo), TWSBI Eco (white), Pelikan M805 (Ocean Swirl), Lamy 2000, Lamy Safari (Dark Lilac), Montblanc Heritage 1912, Montblanc Le Grand 146, Visconti Homo Sapiens (Bronze Age), Platinum Century #3776 (Rhodium Chartres Blue), and Sailor Pro Gear (Wancher Maldives).

Left to right: Pilot Custom 91 (Tsuki-yo), TWSBI Eco (white), Pelikan M805 (Ocean Swirl), Lamy 2000, Lamy Safari (Dark Lilac), Montblanc Heritage 1912, Montblanc Le Grand 146, Visconti Homo Sapiens (Bronze Age), Platinum Century #3776 (Rhodium Chart…

Left to right: Pilot Custom 91 (Tsuki-yo), TWSBI Eco (white), Pelikan M805 (Ocean Swirl), Lamy 2000, Lamy Safari (Dark Lilac), Montblanc Heritage 1912, Montblanc Le Grand 146, Visconti Homo Sapiens (Bronze Age), Platinum Century #3776 (Rhodium Chartres Blue), and Sailor Pro Gear (Wancher Maldives).

Uncapped the pen is out of place amongst other regular sized pens. The only pen that comes close is the Sailor Pro Gear. Uncapped, however, the pen absolutely holds its own. It's longer than the Montblanc 149, Pilot Custom 91, Lamy 2000, Platinum Century #3776, and Sailor Pro Gear.

View fullsize Pocket Comparison Capped.jpg
View fullsize Pocket Comparison Uncapped.jpg
View fullsize Pocket Comparison Posted.jpg

Compared to a Franklin-Christoph Model 45 (Lavender Pearl) and a Kaweco AL Sport (the only pocket pens I have) the Montblanc Heritage 1912 is a little longer when capped. Uncapped, however, it's noticeably longer than the Kaweco and a decent amount longer than the Franklin-Christoph. When posting the Kaweco and the Franklin-Christoph the Montblanc falls to the shortest pen immediately behind the Kaweco. The pen is very much heavier, however.

View fullsize IMG_7996.JPG
View fullsize IMG_7999.JPG
View fullsize IMG_7997.JPG
View fullsize IMG_8005.JPG
View fullsize IMG_8004.JPG
View fullsize IMG_8003.JPG
View fullsize IMG_8002.JPG
Capped Uncapped
Montblanc Heritage 1912 49.4g/1.74oz 37.7g/1.33oz
Montblanc Heritage 1914 102g/3.6oz
Montblanc Heritage 1912 122mm/4.8" 127mm/5"
Montblanc Heritage 1914 156mm/6.14" 206mm/8.11"

An interesting comparison I was able to make was due to a fellow pen collector in my home town who brought this pen to a pen meet and graciously let me photograph it for a comparison. I was a little rushed as I didn't want to take too long so the photos aren't to my standard but they should offer a perspective. That perspective is that the Montblanc Heritage 1914 is absurdly humongous. It's over 20cm/8 inches long uncapped and with the nib extended and over 100g capped. It feels more like a weapon than a pen (which really lends more credibility to this pen being mightier than a sword). Form factor wise the pens are almost identical. The main differences that the Montblanc logo on the cap band of the 1914 is cut through rather than pressed like on the 1912, the threads and quasi-section are metal, and the Montblanc mountain top star on the cap is now simply mother-of-pearl moulded into cap. Fascinating pen but ridiculously massive.

Written review and Conclusion

I really like this pen. The nib has a great feel and the Masuyama Broad Cursive Italic is superb. The modern design is sleek, and the mechanism is fun. The balance is different but I like it and the weight is definitely heavy but the smaller size (relative to it's weight) makes it more wieldy. The act of opening the cap, placing it somewhere safe, extending the cap and beginning writing has some respectable ritual to it. Because of that, however, this is not a pen you take with you and use as a note taking pen while out and about. It's not without it's flaws, however, with the smudges or scratch marks from the cap on the barrel, and the very tiny 0.8ml ink capacity so that definitely is something to think about. I don't know of many people who don't like using or writing with this pen so if you find this pen at a good price I recommend snapping it up! As for the Mike Masuyama I can't comment on the process of getting a nib ground (because all my Masuyama ground nibs have come from either Franklin-Christoph or second hand so I've never sent a pen to him - though this will change!) but I am a huge fan of the end result. These cursive italics are a delight to use.

Great pen, with some caveats that don't bother me that much, and a great grind.

✒︎ ✑ ✒︎ ✑

I've listed all my inks and all my pens in their respective pages. Please let me know which inks you'd like to review next via the comments, Twitter, Instagram, or contact me directly.

For blog updated you can follow @macchiato_man on Twitter, subscribe via email, or like my Facebook page.

I was not compensated for this review and everything here is my own honest opinion. There are no affiliate links.

View fullsize Nib 2.JPG
View fullsize Nib 3.JPG
View fullsize Nib 4.JPG
View fullsize Nib 5.JPG
View fullsize Nib 6.JPG
View fullsize Nib 10.JPG
View fullsize Nib and Mountaintop 1.JPG
View fullsize Pen Bottle Pad 6.JPG
View fullsize Pen Bottle Pad SUNNY 2.JPG
View fullsize Pen in box 4.JPG
Tags: Montblanc, Montblanc Heritage 1912, Sailor, Hirayama Mannendou, Hirosaki Red brick
← Site Update: Donations and Online StoreTwo Years of Macchiato Man →
Back to Top

Blog RSS

✉ Email Subscription

☞ Fountain Pens Australia (Facebook Group)

☛ Sailor Pens & Inks (Facebook Group)